Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Lovely property. Had all amenities that I needed - restaurant and fitness center. Room was a little small however very clean.

Good location for Count Basie Theatre show. At check in, employee noted it was an “Expedia room in the Garden Area”. She didn’t share where it was, had to go back and ask. We went on a hunt for the room and it is down two flights of stairs. The way she sent us took us past prep space for employees. Felt like we were staying in the basement. The room looked like a mausoleum inside. No refrigerator. Plus was at least the size of the room was larger than the one I had previously booked through the hotel. Also when we checked in, they said I had two rooms reserved. I explained I canceled the one through the hotel because I found it cheaper on orbitz. I had to show proof of the email I received cancelling the room. Not sure why it wasn’t cancelled on their end.

The Molly Pitcher is a historic fixture in the area. However, as a hotel, the bathrooms need updates and there are no fridges. Internet can be spotty too.

The Molly Pitcher is a charming hotel in a great location. The rooms are clean and staff is attentive, welcoming, and accommodating. On the negative side, considering that The Molly Pitcher is more expensive than others in the area, the rooms can be small, there was no coffee available to make in the room we stayed in, and the bathroom could use an upgrade. But the positives out weigh the negatives and we would stay here again.

Everything was perfect. Like the location and friendly staff.

should have a coffee maker and tea in room + mini fridge

Nice vintage hotel. More updating, remodeling needed to make the grade

Pros: clean rooms, nice hotel Cons: bar staff was rude Sat night.

Very clean room and courteous staff. Bed very comfortable.

The price was very good compared to prices and other hotels in the area.

Great location. Great common areas. Rooms and bathrooms are very small. Expected a view, as seen in photos but had a tiny window looking at the roof.

Great location, near lively town of red bank. Rooms are quite small but part of the historic charm.

Very nice location! Excellent staff, Rooms are a bit small

Excellent hotel, close to the beach and the Grove for shopping. Very friendly and helpful staff. Complimentary coffee and muffins are served in the lobby each morning. The Molly Pitcher is one of my favorite hotels.

Not only was the room tiny, but the bathroom door didn't close (couldn't move past the toilet) and there was smeared blood on the toilet. I told the staff at checkout. No one particularly concerned.

Hotel is in a beautiful section of town, safe and convenient. Front desk staff showed a lot of personality and made a great breakfast recommendation. Room had a nice side view of the harbor, but a full size window at the end of the hall looked out on the harbor. The bed was very comfortable, I had the best night of sleep I've had at a hotel in a long time. Until I was awoken by room service at 8am. Quick rap on the door and they were in the room before I even realized what was happening since I was asleep. They left when they realized the room was occupied. An hour later, same thing, but we were occupied and didn't hear the quick rap again. This is unacceptable. They know when guests check out at the front desk.

Riverside Ave Red Bank NJ

Hotel highlights

  • Walking distance to Count Basie Theater
  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Free valet and self parking
  • Onsite dining

Molly Pitcher Inn places you within a 10-minute stroll of Count Basie Theater and Two River Theater. This 3-star hotel has 106 guestrooms and offers a marina, a 24-hour fitness center, and free in-room WiFi.


Dining

Sit down for a leisurely bite to eat at the onsite fine-dining restaurant, or enjoy a drink at the bar/lounge. Satisfy your hunger from the comfort of your room with room service. Start your day off with full breakfast, available for a fee.


Rooms

All 106 air-conditioned rooms provide safes and ironing boards. Flat-screen TVs come with cable channels, and free WiFi keeps guests connected. Bathrooms offer hair dryers and designer toiletries.


Property features

Guests staying at Molly Pitcher Inn enjoy access to a marina, a 24-hour fitness center, and free WiFi in public areas. Free valet and self parking are available, and there's also limo/town car service. The 24-hour front desk has multilingual staff ready to assist with dry cleaning/laundry, securing valuables, and luggage storage. Additional amenities include conference space, a seasonal outdoor pool, and coffee/tea in a common area.

Room options

Deluxe Double Room, 2 Double Beds

2 Double Beds | Sleeps 4

Manor Double

2 Double Beds | Sleeps 4

Standard Room, 1 Queen Bed

1 Queen Bed | Sleeps 2

Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Guest reviews for Molly Pitcher Inn

Everyone (9) Couples (2) Family (11)
5
Everyone

By on Aug 21, 2020

4
Everyone

By on Aug 2, 2020

4
Partner Couples Family

Lovely property. Had all amenities that I needed - restaurant and fitness center. Room was a little small however very clean.

By on Mar 7, 2020

3
Friends

Good location for Count Basie Theatre show. At check in, employee noted it was an “Expedia room in the Garden Area”. She didn’t share where it was, had to go back and ask. We went on a hunt for the room and it is down two flights of stairs. The way she sent us took us past prep space for employees. Felt like we were staying in the basement. The room looked like a mausoleum inside. No refrigerator. Plus was at least the size of the room was larger than the one I had previously booked through the hotel. Also when we checked in, they said I had two rooms reserved. I explained I canceled the one through the hotel because I found it cheaper on orbitz. I had to show proof of the email I received cancelling the room. Not sure why it wasn’t cancelled on their end.

By on Mar 1, 2020

4
Family

The Molly Pitcher is a historic fixture in the area. However, as a hotel, the bathrooms need updates and there are no fridges. Internet can be spotty too.

By on Feb 12, 2020

5
Everyone

By on Jan 11, 2020

4
Family Family

The Molly Pitcher is a charming hotel in a great location. The rooms are clean and staff is attentive, welcoming, and accommodating. On the negative side, considering that The Molly Pitcher is more expensive than others in the area, the rooms can be small, there was no coffee available to make in the room we stayed in, and the bathroom could use an upgrade. But the positives out weigh the negatives and we would stay here again.

By on Dec 29, 2019

5
Family

Everything was perfect. Like the location and friendly staff.

By on Nov 14, 2019

5
Family

should have a coffee maker and tea in room + mini fridge

By on Nov 14, 2019

3
Family

Nice vintage hotel. More updating, remodeling needed to make the grade

By on Oct 11, 2019

url importing http://sso-opn.orbitz.com/Red-Bank-Hotels-Molly-Pitcher-Inn.h1975-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Red-Bank-Hotels-Molly-Pitcher-Inn.h1975-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://sso-opn.orbitz.com/Red-Bank-Hotels-Molly-Pitcher-Inn.h1975-p2.Hotel-Reviews