Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Location is very convenient but facility is very run down and seems like a place used for illicit purposes.

Dirty run down looked unsafe...room was ok...ac was great

There was nothing nice about this place. The coffee sucked

A variety of places to eat within walking distance. The facility could use some updatng

Was nervous thinking about having to stay there. Ended up sleeping on my buddies couch. Checked in and out within 3 hrs. Did not even use the room.

Black mold in the shower. Beds were very hard. Manager hard to get a hold of. I've stayed here before this was absolutely the worst.

The place was dirty Staff was abrupt Hookers all over

The hotel loony and hahway had a terrible smell. The keys to the room were a regular key. The doors to The rooms were not secure. I left the same night. I checked in. There were a lot of Strange people in and out of the hotel. I think it was a shelter. Not good at all.

Our stay was disappointing. Good location and was quiet. Room was clean. Bed was very uncomfortable and there was a strong smoke like odor in the hallway.

Room only vaguely looked like the pictures presented on the site. I'm guessing they renovated one room and took all the nice pictures from that. It's a '60s-era hotel that has been kept in okay condition. The rooms were a little worn and dated, but clean. Taking a shower was a challenge, since you needed micrometer adjustments between scalding hot and freezing cold; a very tight tolerance to find the comfort range. That having been said, it wasn't terribly noisy or terribly smoky in the hallways; the bed was comfortable, the room temperature was good, and they were kind enough to let me check in prior to their 1 pm check-in time. I would have to agree with the overall 2.4 rating on the site.

Below average Hotel that simply meets acceptable amenities and necessities.

Customer service was unreliable. The older man behind the desk wasn't helpful at all, nor did he seemed entertained to assist clients.

We found this hotel a bit dated. We think that for what they charged it was worth it. The staff was friendly enough and the room clean. Unfortunately the halls reeked of cigarette and no security present.

Even by New York standards, this was pretty weak. Good location on Long Island but carpets, doors, bed, shower, sink, TV and everything as if time stood still for 20 years. Sad but true. The picture on the website is far from the the

Bay Shore Rd Bay Shore NY

Hotel highlights

  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour front desk

Bay Shore Inn places you within 2 miles (3 km) of Touro College School of Health Sciences and Gilgo State Park. This 72-room hotel welcomes guests with conveniences like free in-room WiFi, free self parking, and a 24-hour front desk.


Rooms

32-inch TVs come with cable channels, and guests can stay connected with free WiFi.


Property features

Guests of Bay Shore Inn enjoy features like free WiFi in public areas. If you drive, put free parking to good use. The 24-hour front desk has staff always at the ready.

Room options

Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds, Non Smoking

2 Queen Beds | Sleeps 4

Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Smoking

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Standard Room, 1 Queen Bed, Accessible, Non Smoking

1 Queen Bed | Sleeps 2

Guest reviews for Bay Shore Inn

Everyone (8) Couples (1) Business (1) Family (2) Friends (2)
2
Family

Location is very convenient but facility is very run down and seems like a place used for illicit purposes.

By on Nov 25, 2019

Review comment responded on Nov 29, 2019

Sorry we did not meet your expectations We will try to do better.

2
Everyone

Dirty run down looked unsafe...room was ok...ac was great

By on Aug 7, 2019

Review comment responded on Aug 7, 2019

Sorry you were disappointed with your stay but thank you for the feedback.

1
Family Family with small children Business Business

There was nothing nice about this place. The coffee sucked

By on Jul 15, 2019

Review comment responded on Jul 16, 2019

Sorrry you had a bad experience at our Motel but thank you for the feedback. Must say that I never heard that about the coffee but that is very individual.Oh well.

1
Everyone

By on Apr 16, 2019

Review comment responded on May 1, 2019

Please let us know what the issue was and when it occurred so we can better try to address it.

4
Business Business

A variety of places to eat within walking distance. The facility could use some updatng

By on Apr 12, 2019

Review comment responded on Apr 16, 2019

Thanks so much for your favorable comment

2
Everyone

Was nervous thinking about having to stay there. Ended up sleeping on my buddies couch. Checked in and out within 3 hrs. Did not even use the room.

By on Sep 18, 2018

Review comment responded on Oct 18, 2018

Sorry you were disappointed.WE will try to to better.

2
Everyone

Black mold in the shower. Beds were very hard. Manager hard to get a hold of. I've stayed here before this was absolutely the worst.

By on Jul 3, 2018

Review comment responded on Jul 9, 2018

sorry we did not meet your expectations.

1
Everyone

The place was dirty Staff was abrupt Hookers all over

By , from New York on Jun 17, 2018

1

not what i expected

Everyone

The hotel loony and hahway had a terrible smell. The keys to the room were a regular key. The doors to The rooms were not secure. I left the same night. I checked in. There were a lot of Strange people in and out of the hotel. I think it was a shelter. Not good at all.

By , from Brooklyn on Apr 16, 2018

Review comment responded on May 15, 2018

Sorry you had a bad experience. We will try to address some of these issues.

3

experience at bay shore inn

Everyone

Our stay was disappointing. Good location and was quiet. Room was clean. Bed was very uncomfortable and there was a strong smoke like odor in the hallway.

By , from New Jersey on Oct 23, 2017

Review comment responded on Nov 14, 2017

WE will try harder to meet your expectations. WE are are sorry that you had a bad experience

url importing http://sso-opn.orbitz.com/Bay-Shore-Hotels-Bay-Shore-Inn.h5704947-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Bay-Shore-Hotels-Bay-Shore-Inn.h5704947-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://sso-opn.orbitz.com/Bay-Shore-Hotels-Bay-Shore-Inn.h5704947-p2.Hotel-Reviews

Frequently asked questions